I don't think it's an either-or dichotomy, really. Not "no service" vs. "excellent service", but rather an array of options. Same concept as having a different entrance for passmembers (back when that was a thing), or a members-only lounge, if BGW had one, and which I would love. It's not like there'd be no food, drink, or places to sit without a members-only area, just that such a place would be an extra level of service, or increased availability of service, which anyone could choose to pay for.
Had a great time at Mardi Gras, by the way. The Jazz show in the Festhaus was excellent. Wolves were putting on a show in the valley (howling, playing), they had Clydesdales out for pix throughout the day. Alpie, Apollo, Vbolt, train, and flats were running; crowd extremely light. Mardi Gras food we tried was great, but the food lines were PAINFULLY slow.