Just a hunch, but I'm betting membership holders are getting into trouble much less often than single day ticket holders.
Single day ticket holders don't have much on the line for misbehaving (not considering legal issues), but a member can have their pass revoked
May I suggest another possible answer? Fun Cards.
October weekend Howl-O-Scream tickets range from $70 to $90 online right now which strikes me as probably being a roughly market correct price for a premium Halloween event at a top tier regional theme park. Yeah, BGW needs to cut out the occasional, SUPER aggressive discounts, but, at least right now, the single day ticket pricing seems reasonable.
That said, instead of paying for one $90 Saturday, thanks to the fucking Fun Card, people can spend a little more ($103) and attend
EVERY $90 Howl-O-Scream day this season
AND THEN also visit as many times as they want through the start of September
NEXT YEAR without suffering the blackout dates inflicted on the much more expensive basic memberships.
Not only does this
DRAMATICALLY undervalue the park and nuke the perceived value of single day tickets
and basic memberships, but I think it does something even more pernicious as well. If you're able to come back for free day after day, week after week, month after month on nothing but the already long-since sunk cost of your Fun Card—something you got for essentially the price of a one day ticket and have, hence, LONG since gone far beyond breaking even on—your perceived value of your trip to BGW is essentially non-existent. Memberships are something the vast majority of guests continuously invest money into with EZPay—that's not a thing with Fun Cards.
Additionally, if you're able to return day after day, week after week, month after month, what is one ruined day? So you got in a fight and caused a big scene—big deal—you can just quickly leave the park and return next week—basically no lost investment for the day you ruined by starting a brawl at BGW.
So yeah, fuck Fun Cards. Abolish them. Basic memberships should be the cheapest way to access BGW for nearly the whole season. EZPay voids the sunk cost fallacy-induced perceived devaluation, membership prices are much more in line with single day ticket values, you don't get your money's worth after a single day at the park, it requires signing a year-long contract with the park, it requires a more notable initial commitment to the park, etc. The type of guest who just wants to visit the park
once probably isn't the guest you want to lure into committing to come back for almost an entire year—and that is the exact market the Fun Card is aimed at. If a YEAR'S worth of visits aren't worth AT LEAST the price of two single day tickets, something is seriously out of wack.
Honestly, I'd much rather see a reduction in ticket prices and the abolition of the Fun Card than a price increase to either or both. I think people who spend $60 per day probably value the experience a shit ton more than people who spend $103 for
a hundred+ days.