I agree with you Joe. I think I detest this event so much(every once of my body hates it, I nearly had a break down this morning) because it ruins a hamlet that I just love to hang around in. Da Vinci's Garden of Inventions(Not Italy Gardens, mind you, whomever wrote the description for the event) is a place centered around one of the main aspects I go to the park for, the landscaping. I love taking pictures of the area, and just sitting down and enjoying it. In fact, my favorite water feature in the entire park for some odd reason is the fountain in the center of it all.
But suddenly during this event, that fountain is covered up with a Styrofoam statue, the beautiful banners that adorn every beautiful light pole in San Marco are taken off and replaced with tacky garland stars. The Wine Barrel photo op that I adore so much is replaced with a red-white and blue bar, and it's not even there for the Food and Wine Festival either, so it barely gets to see the pathways for two months out of the whole year. I shouldn't have to feel completely embarrassed about taking someone who has never seen the park before through what is supposed to be seen as a beautiful hamlet, not a tacky one. I shouldn't have to avoid the hamlet I love the most.
The only thing I enjoyed about the event, as you said were the fireworks. They were beautiful, and the soundtrack was inspiring, although it quickly lost its luster after Independence day weekend. I even got a chance to enjoy the extended version of them, and I was blown away. I won't deny people definitely stay for fireworks, but why waste money on something the public doesn't care about, and a lot of them don't even enjoy? The park truly could have had something great with this event, but the park completely ruined it for me when they killed, and distracted from the beauty of the park's most beautiful hamlet.
In the off chance the park didn't do all the overkill this year, I could really enjoy the event. Unfortunately, this is Scott Gasparich, and overkill is his middle name.