I empathize with people who liked and will miss Wildcat. I've cared a lot about attractions many people weren't really into.
That said, speaking entirely selfishly, I'm thrilled that Wildcat is being converted. I always found it to be incredibly uncomfortable and even just looking at the layout I don't see anything I would find desirable about it even if the pain it inflicted didn't sour my day. Especially in a park with two other (in my opinion, dramatically better) GCI layouts, I'm not gonna miss the thing for a second and I'm very excited to see what becomes of the structure.
I will say this though: In my perfect world—even though I suspect RMC would do a better job—I would prefer that GCI get the job instead of RMC. I know, ethically, the park doesn't owe GCI anything beyond what their contracts stipulate, but I do think that it would just feel "more right" to me if GCI was given the opportunity to "redeem" their first coaster with their new, innovative, prototype track system.
Either way though, while I feel bad for all the people who are losing a coaster they care about—especially for all the kids losing potentially their first coaster—I'm very squarely in the "party" camp here.