So I finally got a chance to ride Finnegan's Flyer, and honestly, I sort of take back some of my criticisms of the ride's location. I'm still not a fan of how the ride ruins the quaintness of Killarney's entrance and that front corner of the village, but from an on-ride perspective, they couldn't have picked a more perfect location. The village facing side is incredible, with its upward swoop that provides a breathtaking view of the hamlet, and that backswing that leaves you looking straight down into the water is remarkable sensation. But I, surprisingly, found the Heatherdowns-facing side even more fun - you feel really like you're soaring out over the water into a ravine, and by running perfectly parallel to the Killarney Crossing bridge, there's a sort of near-miss sensation and an additional feeling of speed. All these surroundings - the foliage, the water, the buildings, the bridge, make the experience so much more fascinating.
Now, I was also surprised at how much I missed the theming on Finnegan's Flyer. Before riding, I didn't have a huge problem with the ride being unthemed. But while riding, I realized how much less exotic the experience seemed without even a prompt to spark the imagination, to give some rhyme or reason as to why we're soaring "over the Celtic coast." Literally a sign or two with an illustration of Finnegan's Flyer as some sort of mythical flying machine, or something to tie the ride to Battle for Eire's lore, would be plenty to give me something to thing about - to imagine what I'm doing while I'm riding. But as it stands now, Finnegan's Flyer is just a big, metal amusement ride, and that makes the whole experience feel a lot less special than it could be.
That said, I absolutely love the forces of this ride. The run cycle is long, and the airtime, the backwards forces, the butterflies in the stomach are all there. As far as rides go, Finnegan's Flyer is definitely one of my favorites in the park now.