Zimmy said:
I have no issue with this show in theory. It is a bit campy for my taste but it is live music which is better than the horrid singing... My issue is WHERE they have it. These are largely marching band instruments all playing at marching band levels. They need to be in a football field not an amphitheater.
Little education here:
These aren't "marching band instruments". These are the same exact trumpets, baritones, mellophones, trombones, tubas that they would be using in small halls, concert halls, and yes in marching bands. In fact when I played, the bigger/louder of my 3 tubas was the one for concert band.
Now the drums are more marching band style, so they've (from what I've noticed) mic'ed up the other instruments to overcome the drumming. And have done the same to the xylophones and other percussion instruments. Their best bet would be to instead mute the drums some.
As for people saying what does this have to do with Italy:
The earliest 'brass' instrument can be traced to Greece. But then in ancient Rome we saw more modern looking 'brass' instruments including the precursor of the tuba, baritone, and trumpet. During the Renaissance Period we saw the modern Tuba, trumbone, and slide trumpet developed.
So Italy really is the 'birthplace' of modern brass instruments and where some of the best brass pieces come from (musically).
On top of that Mix It Up is a tip of the cap to 'Blast' the Broadway musical that started in Europe that is of the same nature. Many of the pieces played in that include French Mediterranean and Italian influences (Parts like Bolero, Villa Borghese).
So knowing all of that I've never had a problem with Mix It Up, where it is, or why they play what they do. Yes I wish for a few other parts to be played but I think it's fine the way it is.
PS:
If you've never seen Blast it's great. Many of the musicians play multiple instruments, can sing, dance, and do color guard moves. Here's some video's of what they do:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OSFe5MrudRE&list=PLnjyIZ03cWRISIjpJa_9IG0E7AVDPhavB