I’ve heard rumor (one person not supported by a second yet) that the change to Upcharge for Haunt has more to do with them trying to reduce fights and incidents in the park.
I believe that is playing a large part in it. Still, to the average consumer, they're being asked to pay for something they used to get for free. If they look at the event and it looks even remotely as stagnat as it has past years, that ain't good if you ask me. Haunt has a reputation for qualiy and innovation to uphold and it hasn't been upholding it recently due to a repeated failure to invest in new attractions.
Cornstalkers debuted in 2011. No Vacancy opened in 2012. No Vacancy has changed a lot over the years, but even so, the continued existence of houses that are a decade old is just unacceptable. I'd even say that the next "era" of current houses are probably at or nearing their expiration—both 2016's Trick or Treat and 2017's Blood on the Bayou.
For a while there, Kings Dominion was on a nice pace building one entirely new house every year. This pace was often notably slower than Busch Gardens Williamsburg's, but Kings Dominion took their time and built absolute top-notch houses. The quality over quantity approach is a good one and I support it. That said, if they're only replacing a house a year, they have to
actually replace a house a year. Additionally, preferably, with a pace like that, they'd also do a substantial update to an existing, aging house each year—like No Vacancy to Condemned.
Even more concerning to me than the timelines though is that, as 21 showed, something has gone seriously sideways with Kings Dominion house design. The quality dive from Trick or Treat or Blood on the Bayou to 21 was so far above and beyond alarming. On the bright side, it sounds like Kings Dominion agrees and have opted to funnel their money into that location again this year. On the flip side though, doing so means they're, again, letting the rest of their event rot on the vine—an event full of houses that NEED replacement.
Maybe I'm wrong and maybe Kings Dominion has large renovations planned for their older houses this year—but if they do, I beg Kings Dominion to add tags to the end of their names—make it known on paper that there's something substantially new to experience. This is a turning point year for the event, please set it up for success.