Thanks to
@Zachary,
@CoasterAuditor, and
@CoasterTalkBob for their recommendations.
My coaster order ended up being: Tumbili, Anaconda, Backlot, Twisted Timbers, Apple Zapple (which opened late), Racer 75, Grizzly, Woodstock Express, Reptilian, FoF, I305, and Dominator. Apple Zapple has the longest wait for any non-Fast Lane Plus coaster at about 15 minutes.
Hard to say that the Fast Lane Plus was worth it. It may have saved me from some 30-minute waits for FoF and Dominator, and allowed for a quick second ride on Twisted Timbers, but that's about it. It did not feel super busy, especially compared to how my home park Six Flags Great America feels on a Saturday, and I was able to knock off every coaster in the first 2 hours.
Grain & Grill chicken was excellent, got it straight off the grill. The mac and cheese, not so much, but I enjoyed my meal at KD more than BGW the day before.