Do you prefer stub threads or hub threads?

  • Total voters
Register or Login to Hide This Ad for Free!
Aug 23, 2017
I'm curious.

On topics that generally get less traction, do forum members prefer several topically specific stubs, or a single general topical hub.

For example this thread:

Dinky Park Fun Land(20 Replies)

Versus these threads:

Dinky Park Gets new Managment(1 Reply)
Guest gets injured at Dinky Park(5 Replies)
Dinky Park reports rising attendence(2 replies)
  • Like
Reactions: Thomas and Zachary


May 22, 2010
Virginia Beach
I can see the need for multiple threads for Dinky Park since it would be several different subject. But at the same time having it all in one thread is easier, since it gets fewer replies, and isn't likely to get more than a handful of replies. Personally the invisible option three is my voice, I'd prefer all one thread unless a topic gets larger and then it gets split into its own thread.
Aug 23, 2017
I've added a third option for no preference.

As the OP states this is mainly in regard to smaller threads so Applesauce's concern is more or less baked in.
Oct 7, 2011
A single thread can effectively slide from “hub” to “stub” and back over time, based on whatever latest news relates to that thread and the Ouija-like collective pull of subsequent group conversation.

Applesauce noted the model I’d call “shrub,” which is a “hub” until it grows lopsided due to a sufficiently large subtopic branch, which then gets trimmed off to become its own “stub.”

The rest are not worth inclusion in the survey:

“Flub,” a thread dedicated to a well-meaning but very simple question which someone then answers immediately via a nearly self-evident observation, thereafter rendering the thread an inert irritation until it falls off the first page and everyone forgets about it

“Club,” a thread started ostensibly to share an earnest observation, but really intended to toss an opinion-grenade into the crowd with the knowledge that the author’s claim to impartiality will annoy and frustrate others who disagree with the opinion being staged as accepted fact. See: this post

“Grub & pub,” wide-ranging hybrid of “hub” and “stub”: a general thread about a park’s food options which immediately becomes interminably gnat’s-ass laser focused on minutiae as soon as any specific meal, snack, drink, restaurant, or other food service area is mentioned by name

“Yeet,” a largely senseless thread, deliberately dissimilar from all others, used unironically-ironically-unironically to the annoyance of some, but which nonetheless wins nearly everyone’s hearts over time, and becomes celebrated to the point of being dropped into virtually any context to the general amusement of all participants
Consider Donating to Hide This Ad