So, after riding this morning, I can say without a shadow of a doubt that it’s a great attraction—but I do worry that the ride runs the risk of being severely overhyped. Is it (as a complete experience) better than Spider-Man, Flight of Passage, and even Forbidden Journey? Yes, I think so. Is it a better ride than all of those though? I’m way less sure about that.
Rise, as a ride, was somewhat underwhelming for me. Many of the effects actually struck me as more lackluster in person than they even look in videos. Being “broken out” of the holding cell? Enchanted Tales with Bell executes a similar effect better. The saber through the ceiling bit? Not the least bit convincing in person. The climax with the window breaking behind Kylo Ren? Just sorta cheesy looking honestly. If you break things down scene by scene... There’s honestly a lot left to be desired there in my opinion. ?
That said, Rise excels well beyond its peers when it comes to both storytelling and really immersing you into a world. The queue and preshows are brilliant—easily the best in the industry if you ask me. Another enormous plus of Rise is the cast—they all stay perfectly in character. Moreover, every move the guest makes has an in-story justification—something Disney was already well ahead of the curve on with Flight of Passage.
So yeah, I don't think Rise of the Resistance is some sort of entirely groundbreaking, life-changing, dark ride—I think its brilliance comes from how that dark ride is packaged. THAT is the aspect that I expect to change what e-ticket theme park attractions will look like moving forward.