Register or Login to Hide This Ad for Free!
Oct 14, 2023
200
645
210
Harrisonburg, Va
When the biggest news to hit bgw in years broke I was unfortunately following up on my own adventure else were. I was actually spending time in the great smoky mountains of Tennessee spending three days of which at Dollywood. Being an avid fan of bgw for years now, me and my wife set out to visit another park giving me an amazing opportunity to view my home park from a different light. I know I view the park under microscope far to often, I see all these flaws but is the park falling apart as much as I feel or is finding it’s way the same as all others parks. This leads me to my point how does bgw stack up against Dollywood for the 2023 season. Let me start with my disclaimers this is my opinion and my opinion only, I will not make it bgw for Christmas town, but i also did not make it to Dollywood Harvest festival, so my opinion is slightly skewed so I’m not comparing the two seasonal events against each other so much as how well the parks handle seasonal events so this isn’t going to be apples to apples in that aspect more of a tangelos to tangerines if you will. And to address the biggest elephant In the room lighting rod is down I did not get to experience it so that is a major lose for Dollywood. I’m going to break my comparisons in to four parts the park, the rides, the entertainment, and the seasonal event.


State of the park

Stepping on to the tram at Dollywood wearing my lochness monster hoodie I felt excitement for the day, I was greeted to the park by tram operators that were fun and excited with the typical park rules and information speech I set off in to the park, ticket sales was another amazing event where they only offer two kiosks the rest were man’d ticket booths with almost all guests opting to just go and deal with real person then a computer screen. Once inside I found the theming to be amazing each section of the park does everything in its power to make you feel like you are where you are meant to be, on a 1950s Main Street, in the hills of Tennessee logging town, in an immersed child’s enchanted forest. This park doesn’t fault in the theming category. Even the food selections prefectly match up. Not to mention the fact the park has actual sit down restaurants with waiters and waitresses. This is something I never even thought was in the realm of possibilities. Having never stepped foot in a theme park not names kings dominion or Busch gardens. Where does Dollywood fault in the park its self just like any park things age and with out knowing everything I can about Dollywood I can pretty much tell you the oldest sections of the park based of the conditions of the facilities. Many of the bathrooms need refurbishment, most things are due a fresh coat of paint, and it seems like the sections of the park with the least traffic receive the least amount of love. When I compare all of that to bgw I can’t help but feel that bgw just falls short in most of this, between the trams not being operational consistently, the theming being lacking in most anything new to the park or in need of a facelift in the areas of old bgw just seems to just miss the mark. Bgw is not terrible but anyone who visits both will feel that theming is just not near the priority that it is at Dollywood. As far as the bathrooms are concerned I have to say it’s comparable if anything with the number of planned renovations I think bgw is actually going to come out better in that aspect.



The rides

On this cool winter morning the rope drops and we are off I have studied the map I know where I’m going, straight to the back of the park I have date with a rust covered coaster the last of her kind in the United States the Tennessee tornado, a coaster I have been told is buttery smooth compared to our beloved Lochness monster “it’s so much newer so much more tech was used” on the way up the lift hill I can’t help but smile listening to that amazing arrow noisy anti roll back system. Three loops later I’m getting off with a smile on my face and a sore neck. This is still very much an arrow coaster. But she isn’t beautiful and no where near as iconic as nessy this coaster is shoved in a corner hidden away no bright yellow interlocking loops displayed in all her glory for the park to see. And that begins to set the tone for my day. As we do with every ride me and my wife step off and we compare notes the conversation is repeated over and over again. Wow wild eagle is so good, but I like griffin more, wow firechaser is so good but it doesn’t have the excitement verbolten holds, thunderhead and invader are rough ass wooden coasters alright, big bear is sooo amazing but pantheon is a far superior launch coaster, tempesto and mine mystery would be way more enjoyable if they were scrape metal. I know these are not great comparisons but that’s the thing Dollywood misses this mark by a mile. Don’t get me wrong there isn’t a bad coaster in this park, there just isn’t currently any great ones. My entire trip I spent missing the coaster collection of my home park. I wanted bigger I wanted more exciting I wanted more. And dollywood just can’t deliver.



The entertainment

I want to start with i am not a shows person but I make a point to hit the highlights especially after a meal before I spend any time on the coasters. I have to give this one with no surprise to Dollywood, this park his a musical element to it that is unfair, music and entertainment just come natural here every show I attend was great. But I couldn’t help but notice something I have ever noticed before about bgw here. Every thing I have seen at bgw almost seems forced, like everything has a slight underlining grasping at straws feel if you will. That is something I haven’t noticed and honestly I don’t know how the park can address it but I can feel that bgw is far behind in this aspect.





The seasonal events

Dollywood at Christmas is something I can’t recommend enough, they manage to incorporate the look of Christmas in to every inch of the park, if you can hang a Christmas light on it they hung a Christmas light on it. They have a drone show that is so good that if the world ran out of fireworks tomorrow I’d be just fine. But that’s it there, that’s where the buck stops there no cast members to bring that Christmas feel. There is nothing to bring in any immersion. The only kids Christmas event is a paid add on event that I didn’t add on. Mean while just weeks before I found myself in Williamsburg smiling as I saw a scare actor break character to high fine a small child and with in a moment fire up a chainsaw and chase a group of teenagers. I know that the theming at bgw has been better in years past but I can’t help but feel like the experience is very much still there, much of that I have to attribute to the scare actors who take on the roll more then Seas does.



If you’re still reading by this point I thank you for even putting up with my criticism. But my take away from this experience is this, bgw is still very much a phenomenal park. But has its strengths and it has its weaknesses. I’m still happy to call it my home park, but at the same time I still maintain my criticism, it needs work it needs attention. My only hope is someone at seas is monitoring the page and hears us, I understand budgets are at thing and they can only do what they can do but I hope they fight to do all they can, to keep this place as good as it is.
 
Right now, Dollywood is the gold standard of regional theme parks management. Whike Cedar fair, Six Flags and SeaWorld are purposely reducing the guest experience for short term profits

There’s a reason that Dollywood is going to operate almost daily March through December next year. It’s because they treat their customers and their employees right. They have something for everyone to do, the park is well operated, and they don’t pull these ghost weather closures to save money at the expense of the employees Like those other three operators do
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Don’t get me wrong Dollywood is the best regional theme park between my opinion and the general sentiment I pick up in the many outlets I visit online. My feels are just that I don’t feel like bgw is falling in to utter disrepair, with no hope for the future, I think it’s just stuck in this corporate structure where things have to fall off a bit before they will recorrect course. Not saying I condone it just the feeling I have formed, after visiting a park that is like you said is the standard of this type of park, that operates more on efficiency and growth, and not on a bottomline solely.
 
  • Like
Reactions: deacfan31
Don’t get me wrong Dollywood is the best regional theme park between my opinion and the general sentiment I pick up in the many outlets I visit online. My feels are just that I don’t feel like bgw is falling in to utter disrepair, with no hope for the future, I think it’s just stuck in this corporate structure where things have to fall off a bit before they will recorrect course. Not saying I condone it just the feeling I have formed, after visiting a park that is like you said is the standard of this type of park, that operates more on efficiency and growth, and not on a bottomline solely.
BGW isn’t in disrepair. But 15ish years ago it was the shining beacon of how to run a theme park. Like Dollywood is today. Then corporate greed became more important than the guest experience and the treatment of employees.

Inch by inch Busch has made cuts so it’s now maybe a B-/C+ class park when it used to be A class.
 
Dollywood is absolutely my favorite park I’ve been to, if you remember my hellish battle with lrod this April, through that I found possibly the most beautiful park (still debating this and bgw), the nicest staff I’ve ever interacted with at a park, some of the coolest attractions and shows out there. I desperately want to go back not only for lrod and big bear, but to go through this park again.
 
Having been to Dollywood this past summer, I still prefer BGW over Dollywood. It felt like many of the coasters at Dollywood were cut short except for Thunderhead which in my opinion was the best coaster in the park. Otherwise I much prefer the coaster lineup at BGW.
I was there for Coaster Con and the food that Dollywood served us was exceptional (the $5 dollar beers were great but available only for the first night). Otherwise I didn't eat too much at Dollywood but what I did have was certainly better than BGW.
The entertainment was pretty good at Dollywood but I still prefer the BGW shows (If they brought back pet shenanigan's BGW would be the hands down winner). I'm also not a big country music fan.
Both parks are nice and in some ways Dollywood pays more attention to the details in their theming.
One thing that didn't make sense at Dollywood was that the location of the Dollywood hotels required using shuttles to get back and forth.
The one thing that BGW has over Dollywood is that BGW serves beer even if it is ridiculously priced.

I also think when evaluating a park you should take in the surrounding area as well. I like the Williamsburg area overall better than the Dollywood area. I found the restaurants in Williamsburg to be better and I like having Colonial Williamsburg nearby.
 
Having been to Dollywood this past summer, I still prefer BGW over Dollywood. It felt like many of the coasters at Dollywood were cut short except for Thunderhead which in my opinion was the best coaster in the park. Otherwise I much prefer the coaster lineup at BGW.
I was there for Coaster Con and the food that Dollywood served us was exceptional (the $5 dollar beers were great but available only for the first night). Otherwise I didn't eat too much at Dollywood but what I did have was certainly better than BGW.
The entertainment was pretty good at Dollywood but I still prefer the BGW shows (If they brought back pet shenanigan's BGW would be the hands down winner). I'm also not a big country music fan.
Both parks are nice and in some ways Dollywood pays more attention to the details in their theming.
One thing that didn't make sense at Dollywood was that the location of the Dollywood hotels required using shuttles to get back and forth.
The one thing that BGW has over Dollywood is that BGW serves beer even if it is ridiculously priced.

I also think when evaluating a park you should take in the surrounding area as well. I like the Williamsburg area overall better than the Dollywood area. I found the restaurants in Williamsburg to be better and I like having Colonial Williamsburg nearby.
Thunderhead is so good man. Absolutely incredible
 
I think Dollywood feels a lot like AB-era BGW for one clear reason: it’s privately owned. Herschend is still there to turn a profit, but not every decision is made just to deliver good-looking quarterly results to shareholders. You can tell there’s a level of passion and love for the artistry of theme parks that extends from the top down.

Walking through Craftsmen’s Valley at Dollywood, for just one example, feels so much like walking through BGW in its golden years. The area doesn’t have many rides, but it’s brimming with landscaping, beautifully maintained architecture, water features, funny signage, thousands of little details, live artisans, one-of-a-kind merchandise, animal encounters, delicious freshly made food (the cinnamon bread, mmmm), and so much more. It truly feels like a town from the past come to life — and at the same time, is brimming with whimsy and charm. It’s clear that love wasn’t just poured into the area when it was built, but love continues to be poured into the area to maintain it and keep it feeling alive.

Browse this amazing collection of photos of BGW from the early 2000s and you’ll see countless little touches all over the park that are just gone now. From hand-carved little wooden figurines on light posts in Rhinefeld to little maps and hand painted signage in New France, you can tell BGW was a passion project that people at the park genuinely cared about. People at the park cared about presenting the park as its own special world. People at the park treated the park not as an asset for generating cash flow, but as a piece of art to improve and embellish and share with the world.

The park, in many ways, was a hobby — the ultimate passion project. It’s how the park was founded (essentially a giant playground for the 1970s generation of the Busch family), and it’s how the park felt for decades. In much the same way that a homeowner decorates his house with Christmas lights just for the satisfaction of presenting something wonderful to passersby, it seemed that people behind the scenes at BGW took pride in presenting their idyllic old-world European wonderland to guests.

Those people are gone. The people at the top only care about one thing: generating profits. I get it, that’s the nature of the beast, that’s capitalism. I say this not as a criticism of capitalism (after all, it was the Busch family that sold the park, and if they wanted out of the theme park business anyway, what was the alternative? Shutting it down and letting it rot?), but as a way of pointing out why Dollywood is such a gem. It’s one of the rare remaining parks whose leaders don’t have a legal obligation to shareholders squeeze the park for every dollar it’s worth. It’s one of the last parks in the country where you can experience a world that’s presented to you, in some part, just because the people at the park care about it and want you to experience it. And it’s a place where you can still feel that same sense of magic that BGW used to have.
 
Last edited:
I have never been so bummed to read a response on here, I do truly hate that I missed out on such a golden time in the parks life. If it could present such an inclusion in to the theme the way that Dollywood does while still offering the fun and excitement that it does now. It would be a destination park not just a good regional park. It’s a shame I didn’t get to enjoy it.
 
I have never been so bummed to read a response on here, I do truly hate that I missed out on such a golden time in the parks life. If it could present such an inclusion in to the theme the way that Dollywood does while still offering the fun and excitement that it does now. It would be a destination park not just a good regional park. It’s a shame I didn’t get to enjoy it.
To be fair in the AB years they didn't focus on non stop thrills like now. While they did add amazing, thrilling coasters that wasn't the whole point, so to some people current BGW might have more appeal. I do miss the uniqueness and details from the past though. No generic uniforms, but one's thematically appropriate for the area. Like said above little details everywhere. And TREES. So many trees back then.
 
after all, it was the Busch family that sold the park, and if they wanted out of the theme park business anyway, what was the alternative? Shutting it down and letting it rot?

To be a little pedantic here:

The Busch family fucked up hard by letting August IV be the leader instead of one of his better-suited brothers. Under his watch, he made some really terrible business decisions based on going with his gut and trying to look cool, which basically made AB a prime takeover target... Which is exactly what happened.

When InBev came in their one and only focus was beer. Thus, all other divisions were spun off including the parks.

Source: Bitter Brew: The Rise and Fall of Anheuser-Busch and Am…

Therefore, the Busch family didn't sell the park, they sold their empire and the buyer then divested.
 
Last edited:
I think Dollywood feels a lot like AB-era BGW for one clear reason: it’s privately owned. Herschend is still there to turn a profit, but not every decision is made just to deliver good-looking quarterly results to shareholders. You can tell there’s a level of passion and love for the artistry of theme parks that extends from the top down.
If I could like this statement 100 times I would.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tursiops
One thing I like about Dollywood is the tweener section of the park (Wild Wood Grove). My kids are 9 and short of the 54 inch mark to ride the big rides at BG, KD and Carowinds. However, they do get a bigger coaster feel than other kiddie rides with Big Bear Mountain and Dragonflier. My kids love both of these coasters.
 
  • Like
Reactions: deacfan31
Just to add a counterpoint, while I think Dollywood is a nice park, I also believe it is tremendously overhyped. My experiences have included:

- Rude staff,
- Mediocre food (in some locations),
- Mold on the bathroom ceilings, and
- Warning not to pull the train”s emergency cord, if you get embers in your eye.
 
Don’t get me wrong Dollywood is the best regional theme park between my opinion and the general sentiment I pick up in the many outlets I visit online

Just wait until you get out to Silver Dollar City. It honestly makes Dollywood look like amateur hour. I've never been to any other park that feels so much like the late era BEC parks I feel in love with growing up. Truly an incredible place.
 
Last edited:
I really enjoyed Dollywood, but it smelled like burning tires the entire time I was there, due to the coal and low cloud weird weather, which also made it never get completely dark due to reflected light. While those sensitive to certain smells seem remarkably selective to what bothers them, I still wouldn't recommend the place to them. I also stopped cutting through the candle shop.
 
Consider Donating to Hide This Ad